The Data Says Hit Driver. Here's When the Data is Wrong.
Why the research doesn't tell the whole story
For a long time, there was a debate amongst golfers of how to play shorter par-4s.
Team “Aggressive” believed that proximity to the hole was always more valuable, no matter the lie. Bomb driver, deal with the consequences. Team “Lay-up” argued that setting yourself up with a comfortable wedge in the fairway was the more prudent play.
Then came the strokes-gained revolution in the 2010s, and with it, a clear answer.
It basically said: Hit driver, go for the green, proximity to the hole increases scoring opportunities.
Most of the evidence comes from Mark Broadie’s research (inventor of Strokes Gained), along with Shot Scope data. But the sentiment I hear most is: go for it every time because closer beats farther, even if closer means rough or minor trouble.
And they aren’t wrong. The data does favor pulling driver and advancing the ball as far as possible.
But still, it feels like the lay-up argument got lost somewhere along the way. Even now when I play with strangers, I hear the proximity argument being used to justify pulling driver on holes that really don’t call for it.
I don’t entirely buy it. There have to be situations where the data skew towards laying-up. Especially for the average amateur who may not have full confidence in their driving ability or their scrambling.
Besides, the data is just a starting point, not a hard rule. Every golfer brings a different set of strengths, weaknesses, and tendencies to the tee box.
The aggregate numbers don’t know your game. You do.
The Data Behind the Rule
Before I get into when you should NOT use driver, let’s first look at why the data generally says that you should.
According to Shot Scope data, every ability level (including 30-handicappers) gain +0.10 to +0.16 strokes on average by hitting driver versus a shorter club off the tee on short par 4s. The benefit is biggest for better players, but even higher handicaps see gains because getting the ball closer outweighs the risk for most.
Mark Broadie states “If you are playing a par 4 or par 5 where the penalty for missing the fairway is not too great, then being longer is better than being shorter, so driver always tends to be the better choice. But if you are playing a par 4 or a par 5, where gaining 20 yards with the driver brings deep rough, a bunker, trees or another hazard into play, then being on the fairway is far better than being off it.”
I posted this question to X and received some insightful comments you may want to check out.
This was my favorite:
“Match play, pull driver all day. Stroke play, nothing wrong with an easy par or guaranteed birdie putt if there is significant risk. Data may say going for it is better but I am personally thinking about managing the stress levels and overall mood of my round in a tournament.”
Before we continue:
If you’re enjoying this week’s post and want access to the entire Scoring Letter archive, I’m running a little promo to receive 30% off an annual subscription for one year HERE.
When To Leave Driver in The Bag
Ok, let’s now get into reasons why you might want to ignore the rule, and pull out an iron so all of your friends can laugh at you. Some of the reasons are obvious. Others will require you to think a little harder about your own game. It’s vital that you know all of them.
